Magic: The Gathering
MTG singles, slabs, and sealed — Reserved List staples through the newest Universes Beyond drops.
9 items available
Showing 9 of 9 items
Blackjadedwolf
2025 Magic MTG Final Fantasy Art Series Nibelheim Aflame Gold Stamped PSA 10 #35
$ 175.00
Blackjadedwolf
2025 Magic MTG Marvel's Spider-Man Plains PSA Mitsuhiro Arita Auto Sketch #0189
$ 899.00
Blackjadedwolf
2025 Magic MTG SLDrop Light-Paws Foil PSA Mitsuhiro Arita Auto 9 & Sketch #1877
$ 799.99
Blackjadedwolf
2025 Magic MTG SL Murktide Regent Foil Mitsuhiro Arita Auto & Sketch PSA #1878
$ 799.99
Blackjadedwolf
2025 Magic The Gathering Promos Amazing SM Spider-Man Peter Disney PSA 10 #0001
$ 129.99
Magic
1993 Magic The Gathering MTG Pirate Ship Alpha PSA 9 Mint
$ 1,699.00
Magic
2025 MTG Japanese Promo Cloud Midgar Magic Spotlight : Fin PSA 9 #0001 Mint
$ 799.99
Magic
2025 Magic The Gathering Final Fantasy Thgh Ages Cecil Harvey #0018 Foil PSA 10
$ 149.00
Magic
2025 Magic MTG Promos Bhujerba, Floating City #0041 Championship-Winner PSA 10
$ 1,999.00Cert numbers you can check
Verify every slab on the grader's own public lookup before you buy.
PSA · BGS · CGC · SGC
Sold in original, untampered holders. Never resealed.
Tracked UPS Ground
Protected dispatch from Sayville, New York, typically 1–5 business days.
Talk to a real collector
Condition and population questions answered by chat or email.
About Magic: The Gathering
Magic: The Gathering is the oldest trading card game and the one with the deepest secondary market outside Pokémon. Two very different buyers meet here: players who need format staples, and collectors who treat Reserved List cards and Alpha/Beta printings as long-horizon assets.
We list both. Playable singles are graded by eye for the standard near-mint criteria — no whitening on the black borders, no surface clouding, clean centering. Collector-grade cards are sent to PSA or BGS first, because black-bordered Magic cards punish even microscopic edge wear and buyers pay a large premium for a verified gem.
If you are buying to hold, focus on cards that cannot be reprinted. The Reserved List is finite by policy, which puts a hard ceiling on supply that no other TCG category has.
Related: PSA grading services, card consignment, and our Sayville, NY card shop.
Magic: The Gathering — Frequently Asked Questions
- Do you grade Magic cards?
- Yes. Magic goes through the same weekly PSA and CGC group submissions as our Pokémon and sports cards. Black-bordered cards need a careful pre-screen — edge wear that is invisible on a Pokémon card is obvious on an MTG border.
- Are these cards authentic?
- Yes. Every graded card is sold in its original, untampered PSA, BGS, CGC, or SGC holder and can be verified against the grader's public population report using the certification number printed on the label. Raw singles are hand-checked by our team before listing. If a card ever fails authentication, we refund it in full.
- How are orders shipped?
- Orders ship from our Sayville, New York facility by UPS Ground with tracking, typically arriving in 1–5 business days inside the United States. Every card ships in a sleeve, toploader or graded-slab protector, and a rigid mailer. Shipping is paid by the buyer and the exact cost is shown at checkout before you pay — see our shipping policy for the full terms.
- What is your return policy?
- You have 14 days from delivery to return any item that arrives not as described, in its original holder and packaging. See our refund policy for the full terms.